Wrong Realm
MoveOnNow.Org
  Mind Your Own Business First
 
 
Total commitment to the military chain of command is critical to its ability to successfully perform its job. In April, 2006, seven retired generals deviated by publicly announcing they feel Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld should resign. Four other retired generals including retired Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Myers, announced support for Rumsfeld.
Rumsfeld's skills and experience go beyond those of most of today's military leadership and corporate executives. His experience includes several decades of top government and business positions. Rumsfeld has been successful by any measurement in each position.
Most Americans have not served in the military. Therefore they have little knowledge of what a chain of command is and how one operates. They have little planning and organizational experience. Therefore, they cannot gauge how important strict adherence to the chain of command is for success.
Today most Americans work in poorly managed businesses with weak managements. Most home front workers today barely know how to dress appropriately for their work environments, let alone how to appropriately interact with their coworkers and superiors.
The seven generals who failed to convince their superiors when they were serving on active duty failed. There is no evidence that their plans would have been any more effective than those that were implemented. In fact, their plans may have been less effective than the plans that were used. These generals had their chance to use the chain of command to promote their ideas. They failed. As in war, failure to win eliminates possibilities.
Countermanding orders, breaking, or going around the chain of command while serving in the military damages military discipline and breaks military code. Such acts confuse and distract from the mission and potential success. Violators are subject to courts-martial. These acts cannot be tolerated in the chaos of war or the planning of military actions.
When a retired high ranking officer goes public, he demonstrates his weakness. He demonstrates that he carries a grudge toward his superiors who -- when he had the opportunity -- he failed to convince of the validity of his plan.
When a retired high ranking officer goes public while the nation is engaged in a major military struggle and his fellow military are carrying out orders under fire, he demonstrates cowardice. He is committing a despicable act and showing disregard for the best interests of the nation he had once sworn to serve and protect.
Return to WarInformation home